Macros should be considered cheating
Forum » Murder Inc Hosted Games » Everything Battlefield Locked
Joined: 2nd May 2016
Rank: Registered
Likes 7
24th Jul 2016

Macros, such as recoil reduction and fire rate modification give an unfair advantage to players who use them and shouldn't be allowed on the servers.

Let me know what you think.
Joined: 21st Jan 2016
Rank: Key leads
Likes 1199
24th Jul 2016

We are discussing this within the admins and how to to take an approach towards it.

It is against EA ToS to use "macros".

http://www.ea.com/terms-o ... f-service

edit: added ToS link



"This community is being dragged down by the balls by Angry_Cuban" - Maverick, 2018


Play stupid games, win stupid prizes

Last Edit: 24th Jul 2016 by some
Joined: 23rd Jul 2016
Rank: BFLevelFour
Likes 0
24th Jul 2016

Well, macros are hacks in the strictest sense, as they are tools that help the player achieve higher performance via automated assistance.  Especially ones that reduce or eliminate recoil and/or modify the firing rate for weapons.
Joined: 21st Jan 2016
Rank: Key leads
Likes 1199
24th Jul 2016

QuoteWell, macros are hacks in the strictest sense, as they are tools that help the player achieve higher performance via automated assistance. Especially ones that reduce or eliminate recoil and/or modify the firing rate for weapons.

I agree with your statement Goat, but what we (admins) are faced with is, the difficulty of proving someone using macros.


"This community is being dragged down by the balls by Angry_Cuban" - Maverick, 2018


Play stupid games, win stupid prizes

Joined: 23rd Jul 2016
Rank: BFLevelFour
Likes 0
24th Jul 2016

An admission should be proof enough...
Joined: 23rd Jul 2016
Rank: BFLevelFour
Likes 0
24th Jul 2016

There are also videos that show the macros in play by showing how the recoil is reduced significantly, as well as how the fire rate for the weapon is altered.
Joined: 21st Jan 2016
Rank: Key leads
Likes 1199
24th Jul 2016

QuoteAn admission should be proof enough...

I know we have evidence of N-J3CT admitting to it so it applies to this case but let's face it, once we start enforcing this is not like people are going to admit it.

QuoteThere are also videos that show the macros in play by showing how the recoil is reduced significantly, as well as how the fire rate for the weapon is altered.

The playlist submitted by Lead0FF is now being reviewed for any macros. When I first reviewed it I was just looking for aimbots and walls not macros, which to be perfectly honest until this weekend I had no idea how they worked or that they were against EA's ToS. I don't even know how to properly scan for them in videos so at least for me it will be a learning process. Within our admin team we have individuals who are more experienced in this.



"This community is being dragged down by the balls by Angry_Cuban" - Maverick, 2018


Play stupid games, win stupid prizes

Obocecha (Banned)
Joined: 3rd Mar 2016
Rank: Registered
Likes 31
24th Jul 2016

It's extremely hard to prove but as far as I'm concerned if you're using this it's cheating. I didn't even know there was such a program to change the parameters of how a weapon performs.


Joined: 24th Jul 2016
Rank: Registered
Likes 1
24th Jul 2016

Angry_Cuban13, While it is admittedly hard to prove, I think those videos show pretty obvious changes in performance of the guns being used. As a regular player on the MIG servers, I would hope the admins will risk a false punishment (with room for appeals) over not taking any action. It's only a couple of people at the moment, but it could very well get worse. I've been playing (exclusively) on MIG servers for >2 years now. Hopefully we/you (the admins) can find a reasonable resolution.
Joined: 5th Feb 2016
Rank: BF Admins
Likes 85
24th Jul 2016

Guys,Cuban has made us (Admins and Up) aware of this. We are discussing in private how to deal with this situation. We do understand the concerns put forward, please allow us some time to address this.

Appreciate the patience :-)
Joined: 11th Jun 2016
Rank: Registered
Likes 1
25th Jul 2016

Out of curiosity, which parts of these videos do people think show performance changes? Because I can guarantee that any of you could get the exact same performance.



Last Edit: 25th Jul 2016 by N-J3ct
Joined: 19th Jan 2016
Rank: Member
Likes 245
26th Jul 2016

macros are hard to detect, they're "adjustable" so whatever that people might pick up on, however unlikely, will be modified in a way that will make them harder to detect in the future. it's a form of cheating but at a much lower level than advanced hax like auto aim/wall hax/god knows what else - and paid for hax is an industry in it self..
and i don't even care if players are utilizing macros, firstly, it's the wrong kind of mentality, and secondly, i'm confident in my clicking ability as long as i'm using the correct weapon for the range. pistols are the only weapon class that makes me salty at times when i feel like i've been (out) macro'd (no, i don't use them). which is not that often.
in other words, if one can't aim, then macros will not make any noticeable difference to his game. consequently, if one knows how to read the game and position themselves with a correct weapon and only, lets say - an average aim, as well as many other factors beyond this topic, then it doesn't really make that much of an impact. another thing, it is possible to listen to the beat of the enemy gun - that pew pew pew beat, then matching the given beat, provided they are of the same (weapon) type. dear macro user, thank you very much for shortening my learning curve.
imo, given our limited resources i think we should concentrate on the more serious stuff.

random thought: kudos to all the admins regulating, you rock!


̗͓̘͓̺̑̆ͭͬ͐ ͐ͩ͋̂ ̗͓̘͓̺̑̆ͭͬ͐ ̥̺͐ͩ͋̂̿ -̮͈͓͎͉͓ͩ̆̓ͪ̐̐ M ̗͓̘͓̺̑̆ͭͬ͐i ͐ͩ͋̂G ̗͓̘͓̺̑̆ͭͬ͐ ͐ͩ͋̂ ̗͓̘͓̺̑̆ͭͬ͐ ̥̺͐ͩ͋̂̿ -̮͈͓͎͉͓ͩ̆̓ͪ̐̐ ̗͓̘͓̺̑̆ͭͬ͐ ͐ͩ͋̂ ̗͓̘͓̺̑̆ͭͬ͐ ̥̺͐ͩ͋̂̿ -̮͈͓͎͉͓ͩ̆̓ͪ̐̐
̗͓̘͓̺̑̆ͭͬ͐ ͐ͩ͋̂S ̗͓̘͓̺̑̆ͭͬ͐UP ̥̺͐ͩ͋̂̿eR-̮͈͓͎͉͓ͩ̆̓ͪ̐̐HA͓͉̝̳̦̘̮̖̬ͧ̓̒̔ͮN͔͎̝͉̥ͩͫ̏s

Last Edit: 26th Jul 2016 by superhanssolo
Joined: 19th Jan 2016
Rank: Member
Likes 245
26th Jul 2016

any chance of publicly posting those videos?


̗͓̘͓̺̑̆ͭͬ͐ ͐ͩ͋̂ ̗͓̘͓̺̑̆ͭͬ͐ ̥̺͐ͩ͋̂̿ -̮͈͓͎͉͓ͩ̆̓ͪ̐̐ M ̗͓̘͓̺̑̆ͭͬ͐i ͐ͩ͋̂G ̗͓̘͓̺̑̆ͭͬ͐ ͐ͩ͋̂ ̗͓̘͓̺̑̆ͭͬ͐ ̥̺͐ͩ͋̂̿ -̮͈͓͎͉͓ͩ̆̓ͪ̐̐ ̗͓̘͓̺̑̆ͭͬ͐ ͐ͩ͋̂ ̗͓̘͓̺̑̆ͭͬ͐ ̥̺͐ͩ͋̂̿ -̮͈͓͎͉͓ͩ̆̓ͪ̐̐
̗͓̘͓̺̑̆ͭͬ͐ ͐ͩ͋̂S ̗͓̘͓̺̑̆ͭͬ͐UP ̥̺͐ͩ͋̂̿eR-̮͈͓͎͉͓ͩ̆̓ͪ̐̐HA͓͉̝̳̦̘̮̖̬ͧ̓̒̔ͮN͔͎̝͉̥ͩͫ̏s

Joined: 11th Jun 2016
Rank: Registered
Likes 1
26th Jul 2016

Quoteany chance of publicly posting those videos?
They're on youtube: 





Last Edit: 26th Jul 2016 by N-J3ct
Joined: 21st Jan 2016
Rank: Key leads
Likes 1199
26th Jul 2016

They're somewhere in the "Report A Player" Section.

Nothing has come it and numerous admins have reviewed it.


"This community is being dragged down by the balls by Angry_Cuban" - Maverick, 2018


Play stupid games, win stupid prizes

Joined: 3rd Jun 2016
Rank: Registered
Likes 134
26th Jul 2016

Thought from an old beardy guy. Cheats are Cheats. Macros are no different. If they can be caught, ban them. If you can't catch them, well there are plenty out there that haven't been caught. Maybe even someone we play with. Only the cheaters really know nowadays.

Bottom line...a person is clean until they are proven not to be. Maybe they be unlucky someday and catch a 2 by 4 to the ol noggin. Karma

Sure do miss the good ol days when all ya hadda do was spec em to see the crap they was pullin.


Last Edit: 26th Jul 2016 by UrbanCamper
Joined: 19th Jan 2016
Rank: Member
Likes 245
26th Jul 2016

Quote Maybe they be unlucky someday and catch a 2 by 4 to the ol noggin



QuoteSure do miss the good ol days when all ya hadda do was spec em to see the crap they was pullin.

and even then good players ("good" in bad ways) were able to hide stuff like wallhax and they would dial in their accuracy  percentage to something believable, making it more difficult to detect.
then there was this guy that caught a cheater, recorded and posted it on quake forums. the only problem was that you could see in the recording that he himself was using an ogc bot. i kid you not.

as for the video proof, it's impossible for me to tell. he seems to be very consistent with his "beat", even in really close gunfights, like at 4:40, where for maximum damage one would normally do longer bursts due to how close the enemy is, yet he does the same perfect brt brt brt brt bursts. someone needs to run an audio spectral analysis and use it to figure out if his timing deviates through the game or if it stays the same, hence proving if macros are being used???


̗͓̘͓̺̑̆ͭͬ͐ ͐ͩ͋̂ ̗͓̘͓̺̑̆ͭͬ͐ ̥̺͐ͩ͋̂̿ -̮͈͓͎͉͓ͩ̆̓ͪ̐̐ M ̗͓̘͓̺̑̆ͭͬ͐i ͐ͩ͋̂G ̗͓̘͓̺̑̆ͭͬ͐ ͐ͩ͋̂ ̗͓̘͓̺̑̆ͭͬ͐ ̥̺͐ͩ͋̂̿ -̮͈͓͎͉͓ͩ̆̓ͪ̐̐ ̗͓̘͓̺̑̆ͭͬ͐ ͐ͩ͋̂ ̗͓̘͓̺̑̆ͭͬ͐ ̥̺͐ͩ͋̂̿ -̮͈͓͎͉͓ͩ̆̓ͪ̐̐
̗͓̘͓̺̑̆ͭͬ͐ ͐ͩ͋̂S ̗͓̘͓̺̑̆ͭͬ͐UP ̥̺͐ͩ͋̂̿eR-̮͈͓͎͉͓ͩ̆̓ͪ̐̐HA͓͉̝̳̦̘̮̖̬ͧ̓̒̔ͮN͔͎̝͉̥ͩͫ̏s

Joined: 11th Jun 2016
Rank: Registered
Likes 1
26th Jul 2016

Quoteeven in really close gunfights, like at 4:40, where for maximum damage one would normally do longer bursts due to how close the enemy is

You have that flipped. Mid/long you want to fire slightly slower burst to maintain accuracy. Short/point blank you just want to put rounds down range. Generally speaking.



Joined: 1st Feb 2016
Rank: BFLevelFour
Likes 6
27th Jul 2016

http://battlelog.battlefi ... 55065222953676367/4/ this has also been brought up to EA/Dice . There are also programs designed to pick out drivers people use to cheat.
Joined: 1st Mar 2016
Rank: Registered
Likes 23
27th Jul 2016

Many mouses and keyboards come with macros built right into the hardware now, a macro is just a simulated keystroke, You an get teh same effect by binding you fire to your scroll wheel, The fact that you can fire the gun faster with a macro or scroll wheel is a game bug. Limitations on the fire rate should be set in the game (think full auto weapons holding the mouse button vs clicking multiple times)
Now do i think its a hack ? No
Do i think its abuse of a bug ? Yes
Is that a banable offense ? thats up to the admins,

Now if some one does get banned for a macro (because its against the EA TOS) Remember that the seeding software is also a macro
Last Edit: 27th Jul 2016 by EXZODIER
Forum » Murder Inc Hosted Games » Everything Battlefield Locked
Please login or register to reply.
Discord App Widget
Chat Box
Angry_Cuban13 2:37 PM
Punkbuster doesn't ban, it just kicks you if you trigger a violation. Anti-cheat services such as PBBANS and BF4DB ban based on those violations
Angry_Cuban13 2:35 PM
Anyone who triggers a PB violation gets automatically banned in PBBANS & BF4DB
Angry_Cuban13 2:35 PM
If you are trying to report players in BD4DB, the BF4DB plugin already monitors PB Violations
Angry_Cuban13 2:34 PM
PBBANS
skipperlipicus 2:33 PM
where can i find a list of PB bans?
MyNamesNotRicckk 20th Jul
Thank you
Angry_Cuban13 20th Jul
Temporary, your ban was 3 days. It'll expire after today
MyNamesNotRicckk 19th Jul
Hello, I was given a ban after I was trolling on your guys's server. Is this temporary or permanent? I'd love to come back on and clean up my act.
-{F©}-ProStock 17th Jul
send you a pm thx
Angry_Cuban13 17th Jul
Hey Pro, send me a PM with the receipt for your level 3 donation since you won't get a form this time
-{F©}-ProStock 17th Jul
Level 3 paid for FcTermial,medfly101.ProStock Thx
-{F©}-ProStock 17th Jul
Level 3 paid for FcTermial,medfly101.ProStock Thx
Online Members
None
Online Guests: 4